{"id":"legal-compare-two-clause-versions","audience":"legal","category":"legal-compliance","track":"legal","level":"intermediate","technique":"verification","title":"Compare two clause versions and flag what really changed","free":false,"task":"Compare version 1 and version 2 of the five clauses in a markdown table. Columns exactly: Clause, v1, v2, Substantive change?. The last column is Yes or No; a clause that is only renumbered or reworded without a change in obligation is No. Keep v1 and v2 cells under 8 words. After the table add one line: Flag for counsel: followed by the clause names marked Yes. Under 170 words, nothing else.","materialLabel":"Your material (attached to your prompt automatically)","material":"CLAUSE COMPARE - Supplier template v1 vs v2\n\nPayment: v1 \"Customer shall pay within 30 days of invoice.\" v2 \"Payment is due 15 days after the invoice date.\"\n\nConfidentiality: v1 \"Obligations last 3 years after termination.\" v2 \"The confidentiality obligations will continue for three (3) years following termination.\"\n\nSupport: v1 \"Supplier will use reasonable efforts to respond within 8 business hours.\" v2 \"Supplier will use best efforts to respond within 8 business hours.\"\n\nAssignment: v1 \"Neither party may assign without written consent.\" v2 \"Neither party may assign without written consent, except Supplier to an affiliate or a successor in a merger.\"\n\nNotices (v1 Section 14, v2 Section 15): v1 \"Notices go to the addresses on page 1.\" v2 \"Notices go to the addresses on page 1.\"","rules":[{"type":"maxWords","max":170}],"promptHints":[{"label":"Table columns","patterns":["clause.*v1.*v2","columns"]},{"label":"Yes or No rule","patterns":["yes or no","renumber"]},{"label":"Cell length","patterns":["under \\d+ words"]},{"label":"Flag line","patterns":["flag for counsel"]},{"label":"No opinions","patterns":["no opinion","do not say","nothing else"]}],"mistakes":[{"title":"Flagging every difference","why":"The AI marks reworded confidentiality or the renumbered notices as changes.","fix":"Say: \"Reworded or renumbered with no change in obligation is No.\"","checks":["r1"]},{"title":"Missing small word changes","why":"The AI skips reasonable to best efforts.","fix":"Say: \"Check each word that changes an obligation.\"","checks":["r1"]},{"title":"Wrong table shape","why":"The AI adds commentary columns or paragraphs.","fix":"Say: \"Columns exactly: Clause, v1, v2, Substantive change?\"","checks":["r0"]},{"title":"Trusting the AI to count words","why":"AI runs long.","fix":"Say: \"Quote each cell in under 8 words.\"","checks":["maxWords"]},{"title":"Opining on risk","why":"The AI says which version is better or what is enforceable.","fix":"Say: \"End with Flag for counsel: only; no opinions.\"","checks":["r2"]}],"hint":"Name the four columns, define when a change counts as Yes, and ask for the flag line.","mission":"Compare two clause versions and flag real changes.","musts":["Four exact columns","Reworded is No","Flag for counsel line"],"rubricLabels":["A markdown table with exactly the columns Clause, v1, v2, Substantive change? and one row for each of the five clauses","Payment, Support and Assignment are Yes; Confidentiality and Notices are No (rewording or renumbering only)","After the table one line starts Flag for counsel: and names Payment, Support and Assignment only, with no legal conclusion about the changes"]}