{"id":"legal-nda-triage-three-table","audience":"legal","category":"legal-compliance","track":"legal","level":"intermediate","technique":"format","title":"Triage three NDAs in one comparison table","free":false,"task":"Build a markdown table triaging the three NDAs against the playbook. Columns exactly: NDA, Mutual, Term, Non-solicit, Result. One row per NDA. Result is GREEN, YELLOW or RED by the playbook count. Judge what the clauses do, not what the document is titled. After the table, add one line starting Send to legal: that names the NDAs that are not GREEN. Under 110 words, nothing else.","materialLabel":"Your material (attached to your prompt automatically)","material":"PLAYBOOK - NDA STANDARD (reference)\nMutual (both sides bound); term 3 years or less; no employee non-solicit.\nGREEN = 0 items outside. YELLOW = 1 outside. RED = 2 or more outside.\n\nNDA A - Pinecrest Data and Northvale Labs\nEach party shall protect the other's information. Term: 2 years. No non-solicit.\n\nNDA B - Orchid Analytics and Northvale Labs\nEach party shall protect the other's information. Term: 4 years. No non-solicit.\n\nNDA C - Halden Systems and Northvale Labs\nHeader reads \"Mutual Non-Disclosure Agreement\". Clause 2: the Receiving Party (defined as Northvale Labs) shall protect all Halden Systems information. Halden Systems has no duty. Term: 3 years. Clause 6: for 24 months Northvale Labs shall not solicit Halden Systems employees.","rules":[{"type":"maxWords","max":110}],"promptHints":[{"label":"Names the columns","patterns":["nda.*mutual.*term","columns"]},{"label":"Uses the playbook count","patterns":["playbook","green","yellow"]},{"label":"Clauses over titles","patterns":["not the title","clauses","what .* does"]},{"label":"Escalation line","patterns":["send to legal"]},{"label":"Word cap","patterns":["under \\d+ words","cells"]}],"mistakes":[{"title":"Trusting the title","why":"The AI sees Mutual in the header and marks NDA C as mutual.","fix":"Say: \"Judge what the clauses do, not the title.\"","checks":["r1"]},{"title":"Wrong table shape","why":"The AI adds extra columns or writes prose.","fix":"Say: \"Columns exactly: NDA, Mutual, Term, Non-solicit, Result.\"","checks":["r0"]},{"title":"Missing the escalation line","why":"The AI ends with a long discussion.","fix":"Say: \"End with one line starting Send to legal: naming the non-GREEN NDAs.\"","checks":["r2"]},{"title":"Trusting the AI to count words","why":"AI is bad at counting and usually runs long.","fix":"Say: \"Table cells are 3 words or fewer; one closing line.\"","checks":["maxWords"]}],"hint":"Name the five columns, say to judge clauses rather than titles, and ask for the closing line.","mission":"Triage three NDAs against the playbook in one table.","musts":["Five exact columns","Clauses over titles","Send to legal line"],"rubricLabels":["A markdown table with exactly the columns NDA, Mutual, Term, Non-solicit, Result and one row each for A, B and C","Results are A = GREEN, B = YELLOW (four-year term) and C = RED (one-way despite the mutual title, plus a non-solicit)","After the table there is one line starting Send to legal: that names B and C and not A"]}