{"id":"legal-open-questions-for-counsel-five","audience":"legal","category":"legal-compliance","track":"legal","level":"intermediate","technique":"verification","title":"List five open questions for counsel from a vendor agreement","free":false,"task":"List exactly five open questions for counsel from the agreement extract. Numbered 1-5 in section order. Each starts with the section number like \"Section 3.2:\", ends with a question mark and is under 25 words. Sections 8.2 and 9.1 are clear, so skip them. Cover the unclear wording on fees, renewal, early termination, data incidents and subcontractors. Do not answer the questions, and do not say what the law requires.","materialLabel":"Your material (attached to your prompt automatically)","material":"PINECREST DATA SERVICES AGREEMENT - EXTRACT\n3.2 Fees. Customer shall pay $6,500 per month. Supplier may increase fees on renewal by \"a reasonable amount\".\n5.1 Term. The initial term is 12 months and renews for successive 12-month terms.\n5.3 Early termination. Customer may end the agreement on 30 days' notice and shall pay an early termination fee equal to \"the remaining Fees\" during the first year.\n8.2 Liability. Each party's liability is capped at the fees paid in the prior 12 months.\n8.4 Data incidents. Liability for data incidents is \"as set out in the DPA\". No DPA is attached to this extract.\n9.1 Confidentiality. Obligations continue for three (3) years after termination.\n11.1 Subcontractors. Supplier may use its \"affiliates\" to perform the services. Affiliates is not defined.","rules":[{"type":"numberedItems","count":5},{"type":"maxWords","max":170}],"promptHints":[{"label":"Exactly five","patterns":["exactly (5|five)","five"]},{"label":"Section cited first","patterns":["section \\d","start with the section"]},{"label":"Questions only","patterns":["questions only","do not answer","only ask"]},{"label":"Unclear wording only","patterns":["unclear","missing"]},{"label":"No legal conclusions","patterns":["what the law","law requires"]}],"mistakes":[{"title":"Asking about clear clauses","why":"The AI pads the list with confidentiality or the 12-month cap.","fix":"Say: \"Only unclear or missing wording, not clear clauses.\"","checks":["r1"]},{"title":"Answering instead of asking","why":"The AI explains the risk or what the law requires.","fix":"Say: \"Questions only; do not answer or state what the law requires.\"","checks":["r2"]},{"title":"Loose numbering","why":"The AI writes a longer list or unnumbered paragraphs.","fix":"Say: \"Exactly five, numbered 1-5.\"","checks":["numberedItems","r0"]},{"title":"Trusting the AI to count words","why":"AI is bad at counting.","fix":"Say: \"Each question under 22 words.\"","checks":["maxWords"]}],"hint":"Ask for five numbered questions, each led by its section number, only on unclear wording, with no answers.","mission":"List five questions for counsel from the agreement.","musts":["Five numbered questions","Section number first","Questions, never answers"],"rubricLabels":["Exactly five numbered questions in section order, each starting with a section number and ending with a question mark","The five questions cover sections 3.2 (reasonable amount), 5.1 (how to stop renewal or notice), 5.3 (remaining Fees), 8.4 (DPA not attached) and 11.1 (affiliates undefined), and none is about 9.1 or 8.2","The questions only ask; none answers itself, states what the law requires, or says a clause is enforceable or unenforceable"]}