{"id":"mkt2-ad-creative-feedback-for-designer","audience":"designers","category":"evaluation","track":"marketing","technique":"audience","level":"intermediate","title":"Sort ad feedback into keep, change and discuss for a designer","free":false,"task":"Six people commented on a draft ad, and your designer, Noor, needs a clear list. Write a prompt for plain text with three headings on their own lines (\"Keep:\", \"Change:\", \"Discuss:\") and dash bullets under them, at most 5 bullets in total, each under 12 words. Put conflicting comments under Discuss, and leave out requests that can't be done yet. Under 80 words.","materialLabel":"Feedback comments (attached to your prompt automatically)","material":"FEEDBACK ON DRAFT 2 - spring ad, square format\n\nLena: Love the blue background, please keep it.\nOmar: The background is too dark. Can we go lighter?\nPriya: The headline is tiny on a phone screen. Make it bigger on mobile.\nSam: Logo placement in the top left is fine as is.\nDee: Remove the stock photo of two people shaking hands. It's a cliche.\nRavi: Can we add a price badge? (Pricing isn't approved to show yet, so not possible right now.)\n\nNoor's constraints: file due Friday; the square format is the only one still open for edits.","rules":[{"type":"plainText"},{"type":"maxBullets","max":5},{"type":"maxWords","max":80}],"mistakes":[{"title":"Picking a side on the background","why":"The AI keeps blue or lightens it instead of flagging the conflict.","fix":"Add: \"Conflicting comments go under Discuss, naming who disagrees.\"","checks":["r1"]},{"title":"Including the price badge","why":"The AI lists every request.","fix":"Add: \"Leave out requests that can't be done yet.\"","checks":["r2"]},{"title":"Too many bullets","why":"The AI gives one bullet per comment, with context.","fix":"Say: \"At most 5 bullets in total, each under 12 words.\"","checks":["maxBullets","r0"]},{"title":"Letting markdown through","why":"AI adds bold text and headings by default.","fix":"Add: \"Plain text only, no bold, no headings.\"","checks":["plainText"]},{"title":"Trusting the AI to count words","why":"AI is bad at counting and often runs past a word limit.","fix":"Cap each part (for example \"each line under 15 words\") so the total lands well under the limit.","checks":["maxWords"]}],"promptHints":[{"label":"Names Noor as the reader","patterns":["noor","designer"]},{"label":"Gives the three headings","patterns":["keep:.*change:.*discuss:"]},{"label":"Puts conflicts under Discuss","patterns":["conflict","discuss"]},{"label":"Drops what can't be done","patterns":["can'?t be done","leave out","not possible","not approved"]},{"label":"Caps bullets and words","patterns":["5 bullets","12 words"]}],"hint":"Feedback from many people contradicts itself. Give the three headings, say where conflicts go and what to drop.","mission":"Give Noor a clear list from six people's ad feedback.","musts":["Conflicts go under Discuss","Skip impossible requests","Max 5 bullets"],"rubricLabels":["The output has the headings Keep:, Change: and Discuss: with dash bullets under them, and at most 5 bullets in total","Keep holds the logo placement, Change holds the bigger mobile headline and removing the handshake photo, and Discuss holds the blue background conflict between Lena and Omar","The price badge request is left out, and each bullet is under 12 words"]}